Bath or shower: advantages and disadvantages, comparison of characteristics

07/24/2020 Read in 5 minutes.
Looking at the bathroom, you can immediately understand how much the owner of the apartment loves comfort. The bathroom is not just a place where hygiene procedures are performed. This is a secret oasis where you can wash away the problems of the day in the evening, enjoy a hot bath, soak in the fragrant foam, and even fool around with the water, imagining yourself as a child and thus throwing off the boring worries of everyday life.

Unfortunately, the dimensions of many modern apartments do not allow for a luxurious, spacious bathroom that can easily accommodate a wide plunge pool or Jacuzzi. However, home craftsmen can arrange even a small bathroom so that it becomes completely functional and comfortable. But what do you prefer? Shower or classic bath?

Bath or shower not an easy choice

Benefits of a bath

Many simply cannot imagine their life without a bath with warm water and lush foam, and are ready to be content with limited space and the lack of other necessary things in a cramped room, for example, a washing machine or a spacious cabinet. And yet, the bath has that attractive power that even the most modern shower stall lacks.

Versatility

In the bathroom you can not only soak in hot water, but you can just as easily take a quick shower behind a protective curtain.

Comfort

A bath with aroma oils relaxes and gives you the opportunity to lie down to your full height. The room creates the atmosphere of a spa salon

Isolation techniques

Even if your bathroom is combined with a toilet, you can use several methods to isolate the bathtub. For example, hang a polyester protective curtain with a beautiful pattern; install a stationary wall of frosted glass from the sides of the bath to the ceiling; or completely enclose the bathtub with a stainless steel frame with glass sheets, creating a real “hydrobox”.

Among the disadvantages of a bathtub, one main one can be identified: its dimensions, which in a small room make it difficult to place additional, very necessary objects

Shower cabins and their strengths

For those for whom the high functionality of the bathroom is especially important, we offer a detailed look at the visible advantages of installing a shower stall. But first, you should know that it can be located in a corner, near a wall, or freely, and this directly depends on the size of the room.

For a small bathroom, corner placement is preferable, since a shower near the wall will take up as much space as a full bath. There can be no talk of free placement here; it is possible in spacious rooms of a certain layout

So, the advantages of a shower cabin:

• Saves water consumption. Even if you use the shower for a long time, you will not use as much water as when taking a bath.
• The useful area is significantly freed up. In a small bathroom next to the shower, a washing machine and a cabinet for a boiler or accessories above it can easily fit.
• Ease of installation. Especially during the installation of a monoblock shower cabin: all elements are already selected in color, size and style.

• The presence of pleasant functions of hydromassage, aromatherapy, built-in radio, reclining seat, and even a steam generator.
• Possibility of choosing transparent, frosted glass, or canvases decorated with a sandblasted pattern

Shower enclosures can be prefabricated, which means you can create a shower space to suit your taste and needs.

Pallet. It must be chosen with a rough surface to avoid slipping. The material can be marble, artificial or natural stone, acrylic, ceramics or cast iron.

You should also decide on the size and shape of the tray, because this determines how much space the shower room will occupy as a whole. The depth of the tray can also vary from 3 to 20 cm.

Walls and doors. If the shower is placed in a corner, it is enough to have two walls, and if the bathroom is small, then it is better to use a sliding door design - it will save space.

Shower counter. This is a set consisting of a mixer, sprayer and hand shower.

Modern shower cabins also have one drawback: it is impossible to position yourself so as to soak up the water while lying in the water.

The post Shower cabin or bathtub: pros and cons appeared first on Homester - Interior design and decor ideas.

Post Views: 28

01/08/2018 dom-and-sad

homester.com.ua

• Original upholstered furniture BUX - an interesting concept from the Dutch Summer workshop
• LIVE AND LEARN! GROWING SEEDLINGS IN TOILET PAPER

Photo of a tile shower tray

Clinker floor tiles for a homemade shower podium are selected taking into account frequent and prolonged contact with water. For cladding, products are used that have a relief or rough surface and a high slip resistance, which is less dangerous.

The most common design is a dense, durable, durable and moisture-resistant porcelain stoneware or quartz vinyl finish. Such structures can have a rectangular, square, rounded shape, be open type without a roof or closed type with a podium, walls and ceiling base. A tray with a side can have different heights, be deep enough and perfectly serve as a bathtub, which is especially suitable for those who, for example, need to bathe a child.

Shower cabin or bathtub - which is better - all pros and cons

Any owner wants to equip his bathroom with maximum comfort and functionality. Therefore, the question of what is better to choose: a bathtub or a shower stall appears quite often. To solve it, you need to carefully consider the pros and cons of each of these plumbing fixtures.

Shower stall: what is good about it?

This type of plumbing is becoming more and more in demand. The main advantages of the shower cabin:

• Perhaps the most important advantage due to which a booth is purchased is the space saving, because this modern sanitary invention can be compactly placed in a small bathroom or adjacent bathroom;
• Less water is consumed and, accordingly, the bills for its payment are reduced;
• The cabin doors are hermetically sealed, eliminating even the slightest splashing of water on the floor and walls. In this case, there is no need to additionally purchase a rug and curtain;
• A variety of sizes, allowing you to choose a cabin not only according to the area of ​​the room, but also according to the dimensions of the body;
• Thanks to the non-slip tray (you can choose its shape and depth), taking water procedures will become more comfortable for the elderly and people with disabilities;
• Some models have a built-in mirror that does not fog up from steam and hot water, as well as special convenient dispensers for bath products (gel, liquid soap, shampoo). It is very comfortable.

And for those who like to shower, there are many additional functions:

• “Tropical Rain” - a nozzle built into the ceiling sprays a stream of water into small splashes, creating the effect of a summer shower. This procedure will help relieve stress, calm down and relax;
• “Turkish bath” - a steam generator creates a temperature of up to 60 degrees, allowing you to warm up the body, cleanse it of toxins and improve the functioning of the circulatory system;
• “Aromatherapy” - some models are equipped with a connector that is filled with aromatic incense. Steam passing through them creates a pleasant smell and helps to relax;
• Hydromassage - water is supplied to the surface of the arms, legs, neck and back with increased power thanks to special nozzles that can be independently adjusted and directed in the desired direction;
• You can connect a radio to the cabin and take a shower while listening to music. You can also connect it to your phone, which will allow you not to miss an important call during water procedures.

Despite the huge list of advantages, this device also has disadvantages:

• The most important disadvantage is its direct dependence on the pressure in the water supply system. This problem is especially acute in high-rise buildings. Therefore, before purchasing equipment, it is better to consult a qualified plumber;
• It is very difficult to hand wash clothes in a shallow tray;
• Bathing small children or washing pets is quite problematic;
• Lying horizontally in a large amount of water or foam will not work;
• Quite a high cost of plumbing fixtures. If many additional functions are provided, the price increases even more;
• The service life of the product, even with the necessary proper care, is no more than 10 years. Pollution occurs especially quickly in regions where large quantities of various impurities are present in the water.

Bath: is the usual better?

Many people still prefer the already familiar high-quality plumbing fixtures and do not want to change it to modern ones. The following advantages of the bathroom can be highlighted:

• An ideal place for relaxation - in the bathroom you can relax more comfortably, relieve muscle tension and calm down by taking a horizontal position. You can supplement water treatments with herbs, aromatics or sea salt;
• It is better to wash while lying in copious amounts of foam. This will help wash away dirt and sweat from the body after training or hard physical work;
• It is more convenient to perform water procedures with children and accustom them to water and hardening;
• Easier to wash pets;
• Easy to maintain and longer service life;
• Buying and installing a bathtub will cost much less.

The two main disadvantages are increased water consumption and the need to allocate a large area for installation.

There will always be debate about which is better – a shower stall and a bathtub. But, before making a choice, carefully weigh all the pros and cons described above and select the desired option.

Examples of lining shelves and niches in the shower

Thanks to the finishing of built-in niches and shelves in the shower, it is possible to create truly elegant accents in the interior. For example, you can use dark-colored tiles and thereby give the niches visual depth, or choose a contrasting design for the shelves and make them even more decorative.

The photo shows a shower room with niches decorated with dark-colored mosaics.

Criterias of choice

Those lucky enough to have large bathrooms have little choice. If funds allow, now many people install not only a bathtub, but also a shower stall. But, unfortunately, there are few of them.

Therefore, let's discuss what we will start from.

1. Possibility to save space. If the bathroom has a small area, and in addition to a place for taking water procedures, it should have a sink and a washing machine, then a shower stall in this case is the best option.
2. Equipment functionality. In this regard, the shower cabin is more attractive, since it has many additional functions, which ensures the full use of water procedures. The bath, in turn, gives you the opportunity to soak in the fragrant foam, and in addition, you can soak clothes in it, as well as bathe small children.
3. Comfort of water procedures. Only your preferences play a role here - some people like to take a bath for relaxation, while others like to restore strength under the elastic jets of the shower.
4. Possibility to save water. After standing in the shower for a few minutes, you use much less water than when filling the bathtub. But, if your home has weak water pressure, then you won’t always be able to use the shower, and all the newfangled functions of the shower stall will be simply useless.
5. Number of family members. As mentioned above, small children require a bath. But if one person lives in the apartment, or a couple without children, then a shower stall would be more suitable.
6. Wellness goals. For some, bathing is contraindicated due to cardiovascular and gynecological diseases. For others, doctors prescribe aromatic or herbal baths. Therefore, choose the option that is more suitable for your health.
7. Fast installation. If anyone thinks that installing a shower cabin is very easy, then they are deeply mistaken. In addition to the fact that it must be assembled correctly, you will also need to seal the joints between the cabin and the pallet, dismantle the ceramic tiles on the floor, level the surface, and then re-lay the tiles. Installing a bathtub is much easier.
8. Opportunity to save money. At first glance, a simple shower stall is inexpensive, but its quality will not always meet the necessary requirements. In addition, when going shopping, many are tempted by the various features offered by manufacturers and choose a cabin that costs much more than a decent acrylic bathtub. And during operation it turns out that the quality of the water and its pressure do not allow using all the capabilities of the cabin.
9. Practicality of use. Caring for your bathtub is very simple - just wash it after bathing and treat it with a cleaning agent once a week. The shower stall requires more careful care. After each use, you must thoroughly clean its walls, preventing the formation of plaque and stains, and constantly ensure that mold does not appear.

As you can see, it is very difficult to say unequivocally which is better, a bath or a shower. But once you have this information, it will probably be easier for you to make the right choice.

It's easier to relax and warm up in the bath

One of the main advantages of the bowl is the ability to create your own spa in the bathroom. The shower cabin will not give you a feeling of comfort, even if you heat it up to the state of a bath. It’s nice to lie in a bubble bath, relax and take a break from everyday worries. Many apartment owners are not ready to exchange a bath for a shower precisely for this reason; moreover, the cabin often evokes associations with a public place, for example, a fitness club.

Water with added oils, salt or herbs can relieve joint pain, help get rid of various skin diseases, and also help restore strength after illness. The bath is a great place to spend some romantic time with your loved one. There are also baths with built-in hydromassage: directed jets of water, beating under strong pressure, have a beneficial effect on blood circulation and increase vitality.

Best answers

Dusya Marusya:

If no one in the family likes to lie in the bathtub, a shower stall can save 1m2 for installing, for example, a washing machine. However, I personally would not turn a separate bathroom into a combined one for several reasons: 1. The waterproofing of the bathroom, made during the construction of the house, will be damaged, and it is unknown whether your workers will be able to restore it correctly. 2. If someone is washing, and the other is impatient... . 3. For redevelopment you need to get permission, and this is such a hassle: (4. A good booth that won’t break, won’t leak, whose door won’t warp, etc. costs from 40 thousand, installing it will cost another 10-15... There is an option make a shower stall out of the bathtub. Put full-length doors. And sculpt a panel with a shower, nozzles, hydromassages, etc. on the wall. Regarding the material. We made the entire cabin in tiles, and the tray was made of tiles, and there was plastic on the ceiling. But This is in a country house. Even if it leaks, it won’t flood anyone. Good luck to you.

Personal account is not available:

We have a shower corner, BUT not a shower stall. The cabin takes up too much space. We did this: we installed a shower tray, installed a shower curtain (glass), you can choose it or order it of any height, and the plumbing fixtures, respectively, separately. It's spacious inside, less space is consumed outside and the ceiling is of any height.

Vasily Ivanov:

shower cabins are different in height, and the ceiling can be made of plastic panels. The question is choosing a color or pattern. ….And I’ll also say that I shower drunk. cab. better not to go! .-it's too dark!

Irine:

We have a shower cabin (although we also have a regular bathtub). My husband uses the cabin. Everything works fine, it’s been more than 2 years now, there’s enough pressure. Among the “cons” of our cabin, I would note the lack of shelves inside for shampoo and washcloths (it is also impossible to attach). And there are also water stains on the transparent walls; you need to wash them often to have an aesthetic appearance, but you don’t have enough time for that... And the ceiling can be made suspended slatted, for example. And if the height does not allow, simply paint with water-based emulsion.

Zhenya Lukashevich:

I have a cubicle, the only downside is that the bathroom is easier to clean

Alena Maksimova:

There is not enough space in the shower stall, but after a week or two I got used to it) ) (the first time I felt dizzy because of the confined space)))))

screw:

Cheap cabins have some disadvantages: assembly with sealant, problems with faucets, cracks on acrylic surfaces and discoloration; a bathtub with sliding curtains is in many ways superior to cabins, and you can install various equipment in it (hydromassage, lighting, etc.), and if the cabin, then IDO

Old summer resident:

Buy an inexpensive Chinese plastic shower cabin (from 15 thousand) with a deep tray, an extractor hood, lighting and a radio, there will be no problems. The only thing is that you should definitely check the supply hoses and it’s better to immediately replace them with good ones, otherwise they will start leaking later, otherwise it’s great, I've had it for 5 years now, no matter what.

Michael:

if it’s less than 30,000, then it’s better to have a bathtub - rust will start to leak on the sealant, the acrylic will crack, it will be beautiful after installation and then a nightmare, and the cabin is like an addition to the bathtub. Many people regret it later

Elena Tolkacheva:

A good expensive cabin has only advantages: strong plastic tray, excellent glass walls, well-thought-out water drainage, no sealants, and only 1 minus - the fan does not work enough, it is very stuffy, there is a lot of moisture, not every core is comfortable.

Elena Patrusheva:

2 in 1 (all the shortcomings are collected)

Seat decoration with tiles

Convenient and comfortable steps or chairs integrated into the wall are most often decorated with small tiles or mosaics, most suitable for curves and curved lines.

Varieties

Shower stalls can be closed or open. Closed - completely closed around the entire perimeter and have a roof - this allows steam to condense, and a sauna effect is created.

Open - partially enclose the shower area, since there is a shower door or partition between the walls. The cabin doors are made of high-strength glass (can be frosted, transparent or rough), and some models have sliding doors.

When purchasing a shower stall, you must take into account that it must be at least 0.8 × 0.8 m in size, otherwise being in it will resemble a rack in a bottle.

Shower tray

Cast iron, steel, ceramics, artificial marble and acrylic are used to make pallets. Each of these materials has its own characteristics.

For example, cast-iron enameled trays are durable, but take a long time to warm up, steel ones create noise with high water pressure, and ceramic trays can break if a heavy object falls on them. Marble ones are durable and comfortable, have a beautiful appearance and create the effect of luxury.

Acrylic trays also look very beautiful, but the surface is not resistant to scratches or damage. In principle, scratches on acrylic can be easily removed at home; you do not need special skills for this.

pros

• Saving bathroom space. The shower cabin is ideal for small bathrooms, as it takes up 2.5 times less space than a bathtub.
• Safety - there is no possibility of injury while taking a shower. They are made from a safe and non-slip material (plastic), so it is quite difficult to slip in the shower.
• Economical - 2-3 times less water is consumed than when taking a bath.

• Availability of additional functions. The shower cabin may have a radio, telephone, sound therapy. Some models have a Turkish bath function - a special roof that retains steam. This cabin helps maintain good health and mood.
• Taking care of your health. You can do inhalations or take treatments such as aromatherapy. Of course - this is only possible in expensive and multifunctional cabins. Some shower cabins help restore your strength after a hard day at work using chromotherapy, or light therapy. Many multifunctional shower stalls have built-in massage functions.
• A huge number of installation and configuration options.

Minuses

• High-quality rectangular shower cabins with good doors are quite wide.
• If the water pressure is low (less than 1.5 bar) in the house, you can only take a shower in the shower stall, no matter how multifunctional it is.
• Over time, a white coating remains on glass doors and walls from dried drops of water. It is necessary to wipe the walls and doors very carefully after taking a shower.

But the dimensions of this type are larger than the dimensions of a regular box. But don't worry - it's worth the purchase.

Video: Shower cabins How to choose and install a shower cabin

A room with a shower is less humid

The cabin, surrounded by walls on all sides, retains moisture and heat, which means much less moisture settles on the surfaces of furniture, plumbing fixtures and things than when using an open bath. Thanks to this advantage, the room is less susceptible to mold and mildew.

An enclosed cubicle warms up much faster than a bathroom. This is a great advantage for those who are cold and are used to standing under hot streams of water before taking a shower.

Interior styles

The size of the room, of course, is important, but when choosing plumbing fixtures, finishing materials and accessories, you must also pay attention to style.

Bathroom with shower in classic style

Classic is suitable for large spaces, but if you have to work in a small room, reduce decorative elements as much as possible and use white tones.

The traditional style is luxurious, but at the same time noble and discreet. Paint such a bathroom in milky, cream, delicate blue, pink, peach, salmon, and calm gray shades.

As for materials, give preference to natural options or their high-quality imitations - this could be stone, wood, metal, ceramic tiles, glass, plaster, porcelain stoneware.

There should not be too many interior elements; select parts in the correct harmonious shapes and install them in proportion.

Bathroom with shower in modern style

The main motto of most modern solutions is less, but better. Do not overdo it with decorations, take care of the ergonomics of the furniture.

Make a choice in favor of chrome, metal, concrete, plastic, glass surfaces. The color scheme is basic, neutral, but bright elements can be used as accents, for example, in textiles.

Country style bathroom with shower

In this case, you can already give free rein to your imagination and experiment. For example, decorate the walls outside the shower from wood (high-quality protective agents will help the material maintain its integrity), and in the shower stall use fragmentary mosaic and patchwork tiles.

The theme can be emphasized by details - a shaped faucet, a sink, a lamp, a mirror with a retro touch. Hang a fun picture of a cute cow munching on flowers. All the charm of a rustic style lies in such simple, pretty elements. Calm, noble shades in the background will help balance the playful image of the room.

Bathroom with shower in loft style

Loft spaces are characterized by an abundance of free space. Of course, if you wish, you can design it in even a small bathroom with a shower. To do this, generously use light colors, mainly white, as well as many light sources.

For example, as a finishing material for the walls, use white hog tiles or light paint that is not afraid of moisture, and large gray tiles near the shower.

Make shower partitions completely transparent or with inserts that make the doors look like large window frames. In the latter case, together with somewhat rough finishing materials, it will be possible to recreate the effect of a factory room with characteristic large windows.

Pay attention to detail - leave the pipes visible, install sinks that resemble solid pieces of heavy stone. Warm brown, wood tones and soft light will help add coziness to the interior.

Bathroom with shower in nautical style

This is an excellent solution for a small room. Marine interiors are light, airy and romantic. Leave the shower stall open and make the partitions made of glass.

As for the color scheme, light sandy shades, bleached blue tones, wood that will refer to a ship theme or resemble a pier are suitable; you cannot do without universal white.

Use wicker pieces, striped towels, starfish. The mirror can be hung on a small rope. But please note that the beach, ship theme should not be intrusive; mark it with only a few decorative elements.

Sources

• https://design-homes.ru/komnaty/vannaya-komnata/chto-luchshe-vanna-ili-dushevaya-kabina
• https://design-homes.ru/komnaty/vannaya-komnata/dushevaya-iz-plitki
• https://blog.gnezdo-mall.ru/vannaya-komnata-s-dushevoj-kabinoj/
• https://Trizio.ru/vannaya-komnata-s-dushevoy-kabinoy-85-foto-895

Tile color range

The choice of color scheme directly depends on the dimensions of the room and its functional planning features. Beige, white, black, grey, green, blue, brown or any other color tile finish, taking into account all spatial nuances, can harmoniously complement any design.

The photo shows the interior of a bathroom with a shower decorated with square gray tiles.

When using light shades, not predominantly white, it is possible to visually expand the shower room and increase its volume. A more unique and unique design, as well as the elimination of minor surface defects, can be achieved by alternating tile products of different colors.

Let's draw conclusions

The final choice will not be easy to make. However, there are constant factors such as the size of the bathroom, the water pressure in the house, the amount of money - all of this will help narrow down the choice.

Bath combined with shower

Considering that, mostly in apartments, this room does not take up much space, you can purchase a bathtub model that tapers towards the feet, or assemble a shower stall with your own hands, leaving space for a washing machine and cabinets. Well, the best option is to try to install both a cabin and a bathtub. After all, both are useful and practical in their own way.

Tile layout options

The classic option for laying boar tiles is a horizontal arrangement with an offset. To create a unique design, you can use a more complex, but at the same time quite original layout in vertical rows or a herringbone pattern. Laying tile products diagonally, which allows you to visually expand the space, is also considered very labor-intensive.

In the photo there is a gray boar tile with a horizontal layout with an offset in the shower.